This is from an MLS scout at the combines (
Pro Player Pipeline)
DAY 1, GAME 2
Game 2 was played much better. Quicker passing, more movement, definitely a notch above the first game.
adiPure (white) was the dominant team winning 1-0 over Trofeo (red). I think that Red may change to red cross with the numerous injuries that they received. Shuleva (calf injury) looks like he may be probably done for the combine. Balc (ankle) should be able to return. I think Ciaran O’Brien may have hurt his hand - I’m not positive that it was O’Brien.
All of the teams were primarily playing a 4-4-2 with either a diamond midfield or flat 2 central midfield. White (flat)/Red (diamond).
1st half:
Red:
F: Xavier Balc, Lukasz Tumicz
M: David Roth, Ben Shuleva, Ciaran O’Brien, Ryan Miller
D: Ryan Cordeiro, Andy Iro, Scott Bolkan, David Worthen
G: Josh Lambo
White:
F:
Ricardo Pierre-Louis, Ely Allen
M: Alex Nimo, Peter Lowry, Dan Stratford, Shea Salinas
D: Matt Hatzke, Eric Brunner, Yomby William, Jonathan Leathers
G: Brian Edwards
2nd half:
Red:
F: Xavier Balc, Scott Campbell
M: David Roth, Luke Sassano, Ciaran O’Brien, Roger Espinoza
D: AJ Kulp, Andy Iro, Scott Bolkan, David Worthen
G: Josh Lambo
White:
F: Maximiliano Damiano, George Josten
M: Ely Allen, Peter Lowry, Dan Stratford, Geoff Cameron
D: Matt Hatzke, Eric Brunner, Yomby William, Jonathan Leathers
G: Brian Edwards
Who had a good game?
* Ciaran O’Brien (UCSB) red - very composed on the ball. Tight passer.
* Scott Bolkan (Stanford) red - Nice in the back. Big, fights to win high balls against a strong opponent (Pierre-Louis)
* Jonathan Leathers (Furman) white -MOTM for me. He played right back and showed me real speed (that I wasn’t sure that he possessed) to get forward. He exhibited good dribbling players. He’s special.
* Shea Salinas (Furman) white - Combined on the right side, willing to take players on with the dribble. Very nice.
* Peter Lowry (Santa Clara) white - Good tackler. Made terrific passes.
Who was adequate?
* Xavier Balc (OSU) red - Typical Balc. Drifts for long periods of the game, then makes a killer pass. Set up what should have been a red goal.
* Ryan Miller (Notre Dame) red - good touches, neutralizing the right side of midfield. Good lungs.
* Andy Iro (UCSB) red - didn’t make any mistakes. Good in the air.
* Yomby William (ODU) white - started out rusty. Looked apprehensive on the ball.
* Eric Brunner (OSU) white - Solid in the back, allowed too much space between him and Hatzke that Tumicz was able to penetrate early.
* Ely Allen (Washington) white - Assertive attacks, terrific decisions when to dribble and when to pass. Good off the ball runs.
*
Ricardo Pierre-Louis (Lee) white - Strong, big body. Step-over beat Iro in first half, but his shot was right at Lambo. Long runs with the ball were difficult for him.
* Maximiliano Damiano (Argentinan) white - Tall, quick feet. Made a beautiful move going over Worthen in the second half that should have gone for a goal but for Nimo taking too much time on the ball.
* George Josten (Gonzaga) white - Goal scorer. Powerful shot that was hit into the corner. Not sure that he’s mobile enough. Big.
Who needs to improve?
* Lukasz Tumicz (Rhode Island) red - Took too long on Balc’s beautiful pass 1v1 with Edwards.
* Ryan Cordeiro (UConn) red - Didn’t Salinas was eating him up in the first half.
* Roger Espinoza (OSU) red - Passing was eratic. Doesn’t defend enough to be a left back.
* David Roth (NW) red - His first touch was failing him today. I’ve seen him play much better.
* Luke Sassano (Cal) red - His passing and trapping was awful.
* Matt Hatzke (Santa Clara) white - didn’t get forward enough. His passing wasn’t
* Brian Edwards (WF) white - pretty good, but continues to have one clearance each game that is a roller.
* Alex Nimo (U17) white - some crosses were into the box, but made too many bad decisions. For example, with just the GK to beat in the box, he didn’t release his shot quick enough.
Who should consider just enjoying a couple of days on the beach before starting a regular job?
* Josh Lambo (U17) red - won’t happen, but he isn’t very good. He calls for the ball when he has no chance at getting to it.
Who do I need to continue to observe/didn’t do enough today?
* AJ Kulp (ODU) red - playing left back today. Not sure he can defend well enough
* Scott Campbell (UNC) red - started in the second half at forward? ???
* David Worthen (UNCG) red -
* Ben Shuleva (SMU) red -
* Dan Stratford (WV) white -
* Geoff Cameron (Rhode Island) white -
Who was missing?
* Eric Avila (UCSB) red - U23
* Julian Valentin (WF) red - U23
* Pat Phelan (WF) white - U23
* Sean Franklin (CS-Northridge) white - U23
-----------------------------------------
DAY 2, GAME 2
Did you say that you wanted offense? 4 goals in 1 game. 2 players scored 2 goals - Peter Lowry and Corey Sipos. The only problem is that Sipos deflected 2 past his own goal keeper. AdiPure (white) won 4-0 over Pretender PowerServe (green).
1st half:
White:
F: George Josten, Maximiliano Damiano
M: Ely Allen, Dan Stratford, Geoff Cameron, Shea Salinas
D: Matt Hatzke, Yomby William, Pat Phelan, Sean Franklin
G: Brian Edwards
Green:
F: Kevin Forrest, Patrick Nyarko
M: Brian Grazier, Pat Healey, Kai Kasuguran, Joe Germanese
D: Mike Zaher, Lucas Fernadez, Corey Sipos, Rauwshan McKenzie
G: Dominic Cervi
2nd half:
White:
F:
Ricardo Pierre-Louis, George Josten
M: Salinas Shea, Pat Phelan, Peter Lowry, Alex Nimo
D: Eric Brunner, Jonathan Leathers, Yomby William, Sean Franklin
G: Josh Lambo
Green:
F: Patrick Nyarko, Kevin Forrest
M: Eric Burkholder, Brian Grazier Andrew Jacobson, Joe Germanese
D: Mike Zaher, David Horst, Corey Sipos, Adrian Chevannes
G: Andrew Katunen
Who had a good game?
* Sean Franklin (CS-Northridge) white - U23. MOTM. In the first half, I was having a “man-crush” on him! He plays terrific 1v1 defense. Additionally, he makes overlapping runs. He megged Grazier then made a 80 yard run to support the attack. Best wide defender. Now, I’m angry for missing the MD-CS-Northridge match to watch Loyola-Fairfield! argh!
* Jonathan Leathers (Furman) white - Continues to shine. On the third goal, got forward shot from 35 yards and it deflected off Sipos.
* Shea Salinas (Furman) white - Terrorizing Zaher (and any other left back in his way). I’m sold.
* Peter Lowry (Santa Clara) white - 2 goals. On the second goal, he was winding up for several seconds waiting for the ball to come. He’s very good. He only played 2nd half. Hmmmm. No goals the first half and no Lowry. 4 goals the second half and Lowry plays. Coincidence, perhaps.
* Ely Allen (Washington) white - Very left foot oriented. Involved in the first 2 goals starting the attack from the left side. He has potential to be a left sided option - not immediate though.
* Andrew Jacobson (Cal) green - only 2nd half. Good touch. Very composed and sharp. He’s money.
* Joe Germanese (Duke) green - High work rate. quick. good crosser. This year’s Wells Thompson? Perhaps. Should have scored in the 1st half, but was caught from behind.
Who was adequate?
* Yomby William (ODU) white -hmmmm. Caught Germanese from behind, good foot speed, because Phelan didn’t have a chance. Had a horrible clearance, ball just up in the air at the top of the box. Needs to be stronger to shield the ball out of bounds. Still not playing as well as I’ve seen him.
* Eric Brunner (OSU) white - played left back, but in the first half - he only had to defend against Grazier. In second half, did well against Germanese. Didn’t embarrass himself. I don’t see him being out wide in MLS.
*
Ricardo Pierre-Louis (Lee) white - Big and strong. aggressive, but not money for putting the ball in the net.
* Geoff Cameron (Rhode Island) white -prefer outside. he and Stratford seem to get in each other’s way.
* Dan Stratford (WV) white - accurate passer, lacks ability to stay with quick AM.
* Brian Edwards (WF) white - didn’t have bad game, consistent goal kicks and punts.
* Rauwshan McKenzie (MSU) green - first touch is raw. not on the field during the 4 goal give-away.
* Lucas Fernandez (Argentina) green - hair and game reminds me of Facundo Erpen. Good instincts. He doesn’t really cover his mark.
* Patrick Nyarko (VT) green - sweet touch. started too deep. He’s still the 1st pick in the draft and the best forward option.
* Pat Healey (Towson) green - played much better. took a full volley shot in the 1st half on target. In the second half, was passing much more accurately.
* Dominic Cervi (Tulsa) green - Good stuff solid in the back.
* Kai Kasiguran (Messiah) green - composed on the ball, feeling better. Still needs to up his level.
* Josh Lambo (U17) white - 2nd half only. came out quickly on 1 through ball, but not too many dangerous opportunities besides this.
* Alex Nimo (U17) white - assists in first two goals. Still many questions for me. I question how quickly that he could help 1st team - 1 year, 2 years, 3 years, ever?
Who needs to improve?
* Maximiliano Damiano (Argentinan) white -didn’t do anything.
* George Josten (Gonzaga) white - bad game. took the FOS award (Feet of Stone). was a detriment to any flowing attack.
* Matt Hatzke (Santa Clara) white - had a good combo in the first half. Long shot that Cervi easily handled. Too weak to hold off forward pressure gives up corner.
* Adrian Chevannes (SMU) green - I’m expecting Adrian to announce that he has a twin that has been playing at the combine while he has been sitting in a beach chair drinking concoctions with little umbrellas in them. I’ve seen Adrian and this is not how he plays. Time to step it up.
* Mike Zaher (UCLA) green - Mike - see Adrian’s entry. Just not playing up to what I’ve seen him do before. At this time, I might suggest that he consider doing videos with pop stars as a full-time gig!
* Eric Burkholder (Tulsa) green - Really disappointed. I watched 4 Tulsa games before the draft and I was expecting to see a player getting around the corner, serving in crisp corners. Instead Eric is like a castaway on a deserted island that can’t get forward!
* Kevin Forrest (Washington) green - Good thinker, but can’t separate. Tries to step over to unbalance his defender, but it’s not effective.
* Brian Grazier (SLU) green - Was awful out wide. Not moving to space (apprehensive/tentative) in the first half. His touch was sophomoric and his passing was poor. He wasn’t stopping the attacks in the second that led to the 4 goals (not blaming him, just he didn’t step up either).
* David Horst (ODU) green - 4 goals on his watch in the middle of the pitch. He needs to do better. I still question his foot speed.
* Andrew Kartunen (Stanford) green - allowed 4 goals. 2nd goal was because he didn’t cover near post. Starting to work himself into a job outside of soccer.
Who should consider just enjoying a couple of days on the beach before starting a regular job:
* Corey Sipos (Akron) green - scored 2 own goals. Congrats. Update your resume. If Andrulis had any heart, he’d keep him on the bench on Tuesday and claim that he had an injury.